This week I began by having my students create a wiki site called TheVeg. I set up the account and password. I typed the directions. I demonstrated editing and log in procedures. The students were assigned various topics and pages to create. I set a minimum amount of facts they must post. The topics and pages directly aligned with the standards that my district has set.
This all sounds great and aligns with my GAME plan to differentiate instruction until…. I hear the voice of a student say, “you know everything we created is not saved. The only information is from the last person to save on the page.” This leads me to questions that has arrived, up close and personal. How do you have students simultaneously collaborating on a wiki without deleting someone else’s entry?
Monday, January 24, 2011
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

Hi Jenee,
ReplyDeleteIt’s such a great idea to use wiki with your students. I know that it really engages students in collaborating with each other. However a wiki is really designed as a way to create documents collaboratively. You start off with a very simple outline and then your students edit, delete and create content that improves the document overall. There really isn’t a concept of individual ownership – the idea is that the whole is greater than the sum of its parts and that the document itself becomes better after each iteration. If you’re looking to keep each student’s work separate and secure, a wiki probably isn’t going to help you very much.
I’m in a similar situation myself, as I want students to contribute to discussion and post assignments, but at the same time being able to keep the log of their changes. For this reasons I’ve found that using a forum (specifically www.phorum.org) is an excellent way for students to build conversations and discussions – just like we do each week at Walden.
So I think wikis are great for what they are, but I also think that we have to be careful that we don’t try to use them for everything even though it is very tempting. After all, as the old saying goes, if the only tool you have is a hammer, pretty soon everything starts to look like a nail…
Thanks for sharing!
Sarah
I have had some good success with wikis in m classroom, but I had to work out some bugs first. I found out like you did that they could not all edit at once, which made it difficult for my large groups to work. However, the second time I did a wiki some of my students discovered that they can edit the wiki at the same time if they are working on different pages. My 9th graders made a wiki where they had multiple pages. This gave all the students that were a part of that group a chance to work at the same time on the wiki if they wanted to. The more you use the tool, the better you and your students will get at it.
ReplyDeleteHi Jenee,
ReplyDeleteI remember this same problem with the wiki we had to create in one of our previous courses. The page only displays what is last edited; however, there was some way that the professor could look at who had opened and worked on specific pages. It might be worth it to have a look back at Understanding the Impact of Technology on Education, Work, and Society, EDUC 6710, with Professor Suzanne Lebeau. This might give you some insights as to keeping up with the individual contributions of students.
I know that I can look at the history of student's post. I ended up recovering the work we did by copying from the history page and posting it on individual pages. I also told students to type what they wanted in a Word Doc. first. Then post on the wiki. I think it will run smoother the next time around.
ReplyDeleteJenee,
ReplyDeleteWow! You hit the ground running. I am in envy of you because Wikis are the one thing I am really not all that comfortable with right now. Yes, I know we had to do one for one of our classes, but it still seems quite scary to me. I guess I am not as technologically savvy as I would like quite yet. I would love to be able to see what you and your students have created. Is there any way for someone outside to view your wiki?
Another question - did you provide a rubric? Are you getting quality or are you having to go back and readdress of what you expect from them?
Trina-
ReplyDeleteLet's just say this was a trial run. I will have a rubric next time. I did set topics for students to explore and set a 5 item minimum for posting.